“Nathan Thomas got him off and thought he should have won,” Hatch said.
“He was held up at the 600 metres and again when they straightened and he only just got beaten.
“He’s the pick of my two by far as American Saint might not run if there’s a lot of rain as he doesn’t like we tracks.
“He didn’t handle the soft going last run in the Cairns Cup but to Justin’s (Stanley) credit he didn’t knock him about.”
Hatch is undecided where American Saint will head next but the Atherton Cup is an option while Sayl could return home for the Toowoomba Cup.
Hatch has named the Jeffrey Caught-trained Flash Aah, who finished a last start third in the Cairns Cup behind The Driller, as the main threat in Saturday's Cup to his pair.
“I think Flash Aah is the main threat to Sayl as his run in the Cairns Cup was very good and anything John Manzelmann lines up is a danger as he’s a very good trainer,” he said.